On Friday, the Constitutional Court delivered a watershed judgment in Werner van Wyk v Minister of Employment that restructures South Africa’s parental leave regime. In a unanimous decision, the Court confirmed the invalidity of sections 25, 25A, 25B, and 25C of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act, which regulate parental leave, and related sections of the Unemployment Insurance Act for unfairly discriminating between mothers, fathers, adoptive parents, and commissioning parents.
The case was initiated by Werner and Ika van Wyk, who challenged the law after Mr van Wyk was denied four months’ parental leave and instead granted only ten days’ leave, while his wife faced the expectation of taking maternity leave despite running two businesses. The applicants argued that the current regime violates parents’ constitutional rights to dignity and equality, unfairly privileges birth mothers, and sidelines fathers and other categories of parents.
The ConCourt agreed. In a comprehensive analysis, it held that the impugned provisions:
- Infringe on fathers’ rights to dignity by minimising their involvement as parents;
- Deprive parents of the autonomy to structure their child-rearing responsibilities;
- Unfairly burden mothers with the bulk of childcare duties;
- Marginalise the role that adoptive and commissioning parents play in the early lives of their children by minimising their recognition vis-à-vis biological parents; and
- Unfairly discriminate between adoptive parents by limiting adoption leave to children under the age of two.
In the employment context, the judgment transforms the law governing parental leave in South Africa, especially for fathers. Recognising this significant shift, the Court has suspended the declaration of invalidity for three years to enable Parliament to amend the legislation in line with constitutional values. In the interim, however, the following applies:
- The statutory period of four months’ leave remains in place, but it is no longer reserved exclusively for birth mothers. Instead, parents may now share four months and ten days of leave between them.
- If only one parent is employed, that parent is entitled to the full four month-allocation.
- In birth cases, mothers retain preference for leave directly linked to recovery from childbirth.
- Fathers may claim leave provided they have assumed parental rights and responsibilities under the Children’s Act.
For employers in South Africa, this means adapting workplace policies to ensure compliance and preparing for an increased take-up of parental leave across genders and family structures. If you own a business, now is the ideal time to review your employment policies and manage the legal implications of this landmark labour law shift. For expert legal guidance, contact our specialists at labour@stbb.co.za.
This content is the property of STBB. We encourage the sharing of our content for informational purposes. However, if you wish to copy or reproduce our content on your own platform or website, please ensure that proper credit is given to STBB.
